The 10 Best Food At Sheetz

This post gives details about the 10 best food options available from the gas station and restaurant chain, Sheetz. I stopped in for lunch recently and was overwhelmed by all of the choices! So, I decided to narrow it down and share my top 10 Best Food at Sheetz.

10 Best Food At Sheetz

1. Fried Pickle Chips

This is, without a doubt, the best pickle I have ever had in my life. It’s breaded perfectly and fried to a golden crisp – it’s an utter flavor explosion in your mouth that goes so well with ranch or marinara sauce. It might not be the healthiest dish on the menu, but it is definitely one of the most delicious.

2. Totz (Tater Tots)

If you’re wondering what a herring tot is, it’s basically a tater tot with a different shape and name. Basically the same thing, except that it doesn’t have to be fried. With cheese and herring, this is a perfect snack for when you’re feeling gassy.

3. Mozzarella Sticks

The key to making these mozzarella sticks great is in the marinara sauce – if you use pizza sauce instead, they taste like regular mozzarella sticks dipped in pizza sauce. The sticks are also larger than your average mozzarella stick, which is why they made the list!

4. Fryz/Totz Platter

If you’ve never had fryz before, they taste perfectly rich and crunchy, with a generous coating of melted cheese on top. You can always substitute the cheese with ranch sauce if you want to be healthier. I’m not sure if this is related to totalz, but it has the same taste and fewer calories than a ton of fried potatoes.

5. Mac N’ Cheese Bites

This dish is perfect for mac n’ cheese lovers! I think it’s brilliant to use bite-size pasta shells because the mac n cheese filling ratio per shell is higher than normal. This makes the dish well worth each bite!

6. Jalapeño Popperz

Our Jalapeño and Cream Cheese blend is the perfect snack to pick up on your way to the gas station. Just be careful not to try and eat it in the car – you’ll end up making a mess! But if you do end up getting it on your hands, don’t worry, I can help you out.

7. Boneless Bitez (Popcorn Chicken)

If you’re a fan of popcorn chicken, breaded chicken fingers, or fried chicken, then this dish is definitely for you. The chicken tenders are delicious, but just be careful not to use too much sauce – it can get messy and unappetizing really quickly.
If you’re a fan of popcorn chicken, breaded chicken fingers, or fried chicken, then this dish is definitely for you. The chicken tenders are delicious, but just be careful not to use too much sauce – it can get messy and unappetizing really quickly.

8. Onion Rings

These onion rings from Sheetz are the perfect side for your next burger and fries meal. I was surprised at how much onion was hidden in such a small ring, so be prepared for the extra mess. Even though it’s messy, I would still highly recommend trying them!

9. The Big Mozz (Burger)

Not sure what a mozzarella stick or mac and cheese bite looks like? No problem! This is the closest thing to it besides getting a real mac and cheese bite. It’s like a big mozzarella stick that has been flattened out into patty form and fried. It definitely gives Mozzarella sticks a run for their money!
Not sure what a mozzarella stick or mac and cheese bite looks like? No problem! This is the closest thing to it besides getting a real mac and cheese bite. It’s like a big mozzarella stick that has been flattened out into patty form and fried. It definitely gives Mozzarella sticks a run for their money!

10. Popcorn Chicken

This is my favorite dish on the menu! It’s breaded, crispy, and full of flavor. This is a great choice to order because it tastes just like the kind you get from fast food restaurants – without all the unhealthy extras. I would just be careful with how much sauce you use – it can get pretty messy if you eat it in the car.

The Bottom Line

While I understand that Sheetz provides delicious and quick meals, I would not consider them to be health-friendly options. Unless you get your dishes with ranch or marinara sauce and forego the cheese (most likely nacho cheese), these meals will do nothing for your health. That being said, they are all very delicious and satisfying – so if you’re looking for a meal that hits both of those criteria, Sheetz is certainly the place to go!